# The US executive order on AI

Date: 30 October 2023 · Era: VI · Everyone · Category: policy · Significance: 2/5
People: Joe Biden
Organisations: The White House

Canonical: https://shapeofintelligence.com/timeline/2023-executive-order-14110/ · Dataset and text CC BY 4.0

> President Biden orders reporting for models above 10²⁶ operations, safety testing, watermarking standards and agency guidance; it is rescinded fifteen months later.

## What had to happen

53 events back to 1943, oldest first. Direct influences are marked *direct*.

- [1943 · A logical calculus of nervous activity](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1943-mcculloch-pitts-neuron/)
- [1948 · A mathematical theory of communication](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1948-shannon-information-theory/)
- [1949 · Cells that fire together wire together](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1949-hebb-organization-of-behavior/)
- [1950 · Programming a computer for playing chess](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1950-shannon-chess/)
- [1950 · Computing machinery and intelligence](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1950-turing-computing-machinery/)
- [1958 · The perceptron learns](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1958-perceptron/)
- [1959 · Samuel's checkers program coins 'machine learning'](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1959-samuel-machine-learning/)
- [1960 · ADALINE and the least-mean-squares rule](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1960-adaline-lms/)
- [1965 · Moore's law](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1965-moores-law/)
- [1966 · ELIZA](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1966-eliza/)
- [1969 · Perceptrons](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1969-perceptrons-book/)
- [1970 · Reverse-mode automatic differentiation](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1970-linnainmaa-backprop/)
- [1974 · Werbos applies backpropagation to neural networks](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1974-werbos-backprop/)
- [1980 · The Neocognitron](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1980-neocognitron/)
- [1982 · The Hopfield network](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1982-hopfield-network/)
- [1985 · The Boltzmann machine](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1985-boltzmann-machine/)
- [1986 · Backpropagation](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1986-backpropagation/)
- [1988 · Temporal-difference learning](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1988-temporal-difference-learning/)
- [1989 · Q-learning](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1989-q-learning/)
- [1989 · LeNet reads handwritten postcodes](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1989-lenet/)
- [1990 · Finding structure in time](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1990-elman-network/)
- [1991 · The vanishing gradient problem](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1991-vanishing-gradient/)
- [1992 · TD-Gammon reaches world-class backgammon](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1992-td-gammon/)
- [1997 · Long short-term memory](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1997-lstm/)
- [1998 · MNIST and LeNet-5](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1998-mnist-lenet5/)
- [1999 · The first GPU](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/1999-geforce-256/)
- [2003 · A neural probabilistic language model](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2003-neural-language-model/)
- [2006 · Deep belief networks and the word 'deep'](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2006-deep-belief-nets/)
- [2007 · CUDA](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2007-cuda/)
- [2009 · Deep learning moves to GPUs](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2009-gpu-deep-learning/)
- [2009 · ImageNet](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2009-imagenet/)
- [2010 · Rectified linear units](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2010-relu/)
- [2012 · Google Brain's network discovers cats](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2012-google-brain-cat/)
- [2012 · Dropout](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2012-dropout/)
- [2012 · AlexNet wins ImageNet](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2012-alexnet/)
- [2013 · Deep Q-networks play Atari](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2013-dqn/)
- [2014 · Superintelligence](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2014-superintelligence/)
- [2014 · Attention](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2014-bahdanau-attention/)
- [2014 · Sequence to sequence learning](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2014-seq2seq/)
- [2015 · Batch normalisation](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2015-batchnorm/)
- [2015 · Residual networks](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2015-resnet/)
- [2017 · The Asilomar AI Principles](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2017-asilomar-principles/)
- [2017 · Attention is all you need](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2017-attention-is-all-you-need/)
- [2017 · Deep reinforcement learning from human preferences](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2017-rl-from-human-preferences/)
- [2018 · GPT: generative pre-training](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2018-gpt-1/)
- [2019 · GPT-2 and the model too dangerous to release](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2019-gpt-2/)
- [2020 · Scaling laws for neural language models](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2020-scaling-laws/)
- [2020 · GPT-3](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2020-gpt-3/)
- [2020 · Learning to summarise from human feedback](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2020-rlhf-summarisation/)
- [2022 · InstructGPT](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2022-instructgpt/)
- [2022 · ChatGPT](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2022-chatgpt/)
- [2023 · GPT-4](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2023-gpt-4/) *direct*
- [2023 · 'Pause Giant AI Experiments'](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2023-pause-letter/) *direct*

Executive Order 14110, signed on 30 October 2023, was at 111 pages the longest of Joe Biden's presidency, and the first binding American rule aimed at frontier models. Its most concrete provision used the Defense Production Act to require any company training a model with more than 10²⁶ floating-point operations, or acquiring a computing cluster large enough to do so, to tell the government and to share the results of its safety tests. Beyond that it directed agencies: standards for red-teaming from NIST, guidance on watermarking synthetic content, rules on AI in housing, hiring and healthcare, and a programme to bring in foreign talent.

The compute threshold, a number rather than a description of capability, was the order's lasting idea. The EU adopted 10²⁵ for its own definition of systemic risk, and California's vetoed SB 1047 borrowed the figure.

The order was revoked on 20 January 2025, the first day of the Trump administration, as a barrier to innovation, and replaced in July by an action plan that kept the export controls and dropped the safety requirements. The reporting threshold survived in practice because the companies had already built the process. The order is on this timeline as the high-water mark of the American government's attempt to regulate the models directly.

## What it led to

4 events downstream, through 2026.

Built on it directly:

- [2025 · America's AI Action Plan](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2025-ai-action-plan/)

And, through them, by era:

- VII · Agents: 3 events

## Sources

- [Executive Order 14110: Safe, Secure, and Trustworthy Development and Use of Artificial Intelligence (Federal Register, 1 November 2023)](https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2023/11/01/2023-24283/safe-secure-and-trustworthy-development-and-use-of-artificial-intelligence) — archive

---

The Shape of Intelligence by Jamie McKaye (https://jamiemckaye.com) · Markdown mirror of https://shapeofintelligence.com/timeline/2023-executive-order-14110/

Before: [2023 · Hinton leaves Google to warn about AI](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2023-hinton-leaves-google/) · After: [2023 · The Bletchley Declaration](https://shapeofintelligence.com/md/timeline/2023-bletchley-declaration/)
